Those recurring domains are the pages your category's answers are being built from. Visit each one, look for yourself, and note whether you are absent, listed with stale details, or filed under the wrong category. That list is your task list, and you did not have to guess at it.
Do this yourself at least once even if you intend to hire somebody. Reading twenty raw answers about your own market teaches you more about this channel in half an hour than any proposal will, and it makes you a considerably harder client to mislead. You will recognise immediately whether an agency's baseline resembles what you found.
How You Will Know It Is Working Ask for the raw answers, not a score. A credible report shows you the exact prompts, the exact text an assistant returned, and which pages were cited. You should be able to read it and form your own judgement without trusting anyone's index.
If your organic impressions held steady while clicks fell, you have probably met this already. An AI generated summary now sits above the results for a large share of informational queries, answers the question in place, and leaves the ten blue links below it with less to do.
This is where the two disciplines meet. Work done to make pages quotable for assistants tends to help here as well, because the underlying problem is the same. A model is looking for a passage it can lift and attribute.
Save the document and the date. In three months you will run the same ten prompts again, and the comparison is the only thing that will tell you whether anything you did in between mattered. ai visibility agency
In this case there is something real underneath. The plumbing of how people find suppliers has changed, and the work required has changed with it. Here is the whole idea explained without the acronyms, aimed at someone who wants to understand the decision rather than do the job. ai visibility agency
Bring one other person from the business, ideally from sales. They will spot inaccuracies in how you are described that a marketing reader skims past, and they will tell you within minutes whether the prompts sound like real customers. That second opinion costs half an hour and prevents the most common flaw in a self run audit, which is a set of questions written in the company's own language.
You can do this yourself in about half an hour, with no subscriptions and no technical knowledge. It will not be as thorough as a full engagement, and it is more than enough to establish whether you have a problem and roughly what kind.
Prioritise by your own citation data rather than by prestige. A trade directory nobody has heard of that appears in half your category's answers is worth more attention than a well known publication that never gets cited.
ai visibility agencyA third response, attempting to manipulate the review platform, fails for mechanical as well as ethical reasons. Fabricated accounts tend to be uniform in language and timing, which is the pattern that gets discounted, and platforms enforce against it with increasing effectiveness.
The Corroboration Reason Any system that weighted self description heavily would be trivially manipulable, so independent agreement carries more weight than assertion. A review platform aggregates many independent accounts, which is a strong signal by construction.
Writing to Be Quoted, Not to Persuade Most marketing copy is constructed to move somebody through an argument. Generated answers do not consume arguments, they extract claims, which means the persuasive structure most copywriters were trained in produces text with nothing to attach a citation to.
Read the Source List Before the Prose Where citations are shown, list every domain and count how often each appears. This is the single most useful output of the whole exercise, and most people skip it because the prose is more interesting.
It is also worth resisting the reflex to prune. Pages that lost their click frequently still earn citations, and a cited page keeps working at the moment somebody is deciding. Deleting a well written answer because its sessions fell removes you from the summary as well as from the results, which converts a partial loss into a total one.
Present but described wrongly means a source problem, and the source list tells you which page to correct. Present and accurate on definitional prompts but absent on the who should I hire prompts means your category presence is fine and your commercial positioning is not corroborated anywhere independent.
Two asking who to hire or buy from for the thing you sell. Two describing the problem your product solves without naming the category. Two comparing named competitors. Two asking about a specific situation your best customers are in. One asking directly who your company is. One asking whether your company is any good.
Pair your name with your sector and location consistently, rather than letting it appear alone. Correct third party listings that conflate you with the other business. Where the confusion is entrenched, consider whether a consistent descriptive phrase used alongside the name in all coverage is worth adopting.